Garmin has long been a leader in the smartwatch and sports watch market, consistently delivering high-quality products tailored to various user needs. Today, we’ll be diving into a detailed comparison of the Garmin Instinct 3 vs. Fenix 8, exploring their hardware, software, features, and performance across multiple activities such as cycling, running, open water swimming, and hiking.
Both watches have been rigorously tested side by side, and while they share some similarities, the differences in pricing, features, and hardware make for an interesting evaluation.
Pricing and Value
The Fenix 8 is priced significantly higher than the Instinct 3, often costing twice as much. However, this premium comes with additional features—somewhere between 70 and 90 more core functions—which cater to users who demand advanced capabilities. The key question is whether these additional features justify the price for most users.
Interestingly, Garmin offers alternative models, like the Epix Gen 2, that include many of the Fenix 8’s features at a lower price point, potentially making them a “sleeper” choice for those seeking value without compromising on advanced functionality.
Display and Build Quality
Display Types
The first key distinction between the models lies in the display types offered. Both product lines feature two options: an AMOLED display and an M-based display. The AMOLED display delivers vibrant, colorful, and visually brilliant imagery, making it ideal for users who prioritize a sharp and vivid viewing experience. Conversely, the M-based display—found on devices like the Instinct series—is available in both black-and-white and color versions. While the M-based color display lacks the vibrancy of AMOLED, it compensates with significantly extended battery life.
For example, the Instinct with an M-based display can achieve unlimited battery life in certain modes, making it perfect for long-lasting usage. If you prefer visual brilliance and typically use your device in darker or low-light environments, AMOLED is the way to go. Battery life concerns are minimal, as both display types offer solid performance tailored to different user preferences.
Material and Durability
Durability and material options are another important aspect of these product lines. The Fenix series offers premium material choices like sapphire glass and titanium, providing a rugged and high-end feel for users seeking a combination of elegance and strength. These materials enhance scratch resistance and overall durability, ensuring the device can withstand harsh conditions.
In contrast, the Instinct series focuses more on practicality and reliability. While it may lack high-end materials like sapphire and titanium, the Instinct models deliver excellent toughness with durable plastics and Gorilla Glass, catering to users with active, outdoor-oriented lifestyles.
Sizes and Weight
When it comes to size, the Fenix series offers three size options: 43mm, 47mm, and 51mm, accommodating a wide range of wrist sizes and preferences. There’s also a 40mm size for the Fenix E, though this model deviates from the core Fenix lineup and is considered a niche offering.
On the other hand, the Instinct series comes in two core sizes: 45mm and 50mm, with no additional options for smaller wrists. Both series ensure a comfortable fit across their respective size ranges, though the Fenix lineup provides greater customization in sizing.
For users considering the trade-offs, the Fenix series offers higher-end materials and broader size options, while the Instinct series focuses on practicality, lightweight builds, and extended battery performance. Ultimately, your choice between these devices will depend on whether you prioritize premium materials and vibrant displays or extended battery life and rugged reliability.
- See also:
- HMD Fusion Review: Reviving the Modular Smartphone Dream
- Garmin Instinct 3: Tips & Tricks to Unlock Hidden Features
Hardware Features
Touchscreen and Controls
One of the key distinctions between the two models is the presence of a touchscreen. The Fenix 8 boasts a touchscreen display, making navigation more intuitive and user-friendly. This feature is absent on the Instinct 3, which relies entirely on physical buttons for control. While the buttons on the Instinct 3 provide reliability and durability, especially in outdoor or wet conditions, the absence of a touchscreen might be a surprise, particularly for the AMOLED versions.
Additionally, the Fenix 8 introduces inductive buttons, which are leak-proof, eliminating the need for O-rings and enhancing durability against water ingress. The Instinct 3, on the other hand, uses traditional button designs with O-rings, which, while proven and effective, might not be as advanced in waterproofing as the Fenix 8.
Speaker and Microphone
A standout feature of the Fenix 8 is the inclusion of a speaker and microphone. This allows the device to play music, enable voice calls, and interact with voice assistants. In contrast, the Instinct 3 only includes a beeper for tones and navigation alerts, lacking the multimedia and communication capabilities of the Fenix 8.
The Fenix 8 also supports Wi-Fi connectivity, enabling wireless music syncing and downloading. The Instinct 3 does not have Wi-Fi, which limits its connectivity options. Similarly, the Fenix 8 offers offline music storage, a feature not available on the Instinct 3, further emphasizing its multimedia focus.
Optical Heart Rate Sensor
The Fenix 8 features Garmin’s latest Gen 5 Elevate Optical Heart Rate Sensor, which includes ECG capabilities and wrist temperature measurement. This sensor delivers higher accuracy, especially in challenging conditions like high-intensity workouts or cold environments.
The Instinct 3, equipped with the older Gen 4 sensor, performs adequately under standard conditions but struggles in more demanding scenarios. For instance, during interval runs in cooler temperatures, the Gen 4 sensor showed less accuracy compared to the Gen 5 unit, which remained consistent. The added precision and features of the Gen 5 sensor make the Fenix 8 a clear winner for fitness enthusiasts who prioritize accurate health metrics.
Other Hardware Features
The Fenix 8 includes a depth gauge capable of measuring depths up to 40 meters, making it suitable for both scuba diving and free diving. While both models share a 100m water resistance rating, the depth gauge is exclusive to the Fenix 8, catering to diving activities.
In terms of materials, the Fenix 8 offers premium options such as stainless steel and titanium, with a metal backing for added durability. The Instinct 3, on the other hand, uses a plastic case with a metal band for additional strength. The plastic design contributes to its lighter weight, making it more comfortable for extended wear.
Regarding size and weight, the Fenix 8 comes in 43mm, 47mm, and 51mm sizes, while the Instinct 3 is available in 45mm and 50mm. Despite the size similarities, the lighter weight of the Instinct 3 makes it feel smaller and more manageable compared to the heavier Fenix 8, particularly in larger sizes.
Finally, the solar panel technology differs between the two models. The Instinct 3 has a more addressable solar area, which contributes to its exceptional battery performance compared to the Fenix 8. Both models, however, share core features like Garmin Pay and excellent waterproof ratings, ensuring robust performance across a variety of conditions.
Battery Differences
Smartwatch Mode and Always-On Display
Battery performance is a critical factor for any wearable, and Garmin offers different specifications for various modes. In Smartwatch Mode, which often includes the always-on display (especially on AMOLED models), both the Fenix 8 and Instinct 3 deliver impressive results. Garmin’s claims are accurate based on testing, with both devices meeting their advertised battery life.
For users who prioritize vivid displays, the AMOLED models provide a bright and colorful experience without significantly compromising battery life in Smartwatch Mode. However, users of the Instinct 3 Solar Edition benefit from extended battery life due to its solar capabilities, especially in sunny environments.
GPS Modes
The GPS modes highlight a major difference between these two devices. The Fenix 8 and Instinct 3 offer multi-band GPS with SatIQ for enhanced accuracy, but the Instinct 3 shines in its GPS-only mode, particularly in its Solar Edition. This mode allows for an unlimited power supply under favorable solar conditions, making it ideal for long outdoor adventures where recharging might not be an option.
While the Fenix 8 also supports solar charging, its smaller addressable solar area compared to the Instinct 3 means it doesn’t quite achieve the same level of extended battery life. This makes the Instinct 3 Solar Edition a better choice for those prioritizing longevity over precision in GPS tracking.
AMOLED vs. Solar Displays
The choice of display type significantly impacts battery performance. AMOLED displays, available on both the Fenix 8 and Instinct 3, consume more power but deliver a vibrant viewing experience. In contrast, solar-powered black-and-white displays on the Instinct 3 are optimized for maximum efficiency, enabling longer use, especially in GPS modes.
Users who prefer an always-on AMOLED display might find the Fenix 8 more versatile, while those prioritizing extreme battery life will benefit from the solar-powered options of the Instinct 3.
Practical Use and Real-World Performance
In real-world scenarios, both devices excel in their respective strengths. The Fenix 8 offers a balance of features and battery life, ideal for users who need high-end functionality and mapping without constant recharging. On the other hand, the Instinct 3, especially the Solar Edition, is perfect for endurance athletes, hikers, or anyone requiring long-lasting performance in remote locations.
Beyond Battery Life
While battery performance is a key differentiator, the devices also vary in software capabilities tied to hardware differences. For instance, the Fenix 8 supports advanced features like offline mapping, ECG detection, and voice assistant integration, all of which impact battery usage but provide a richer experience for tech-savvy users.
In contrast, the Instinct 3 sacrifices some of these advanced features to deliver unparalleled efficiency in core activities, particularly in outdoor environments. This makes it a more focused device, appealing to users who value battery life over additional features.
Summary of Battery Differences
To summarize:
- Smartwatch Mode: Both devices perform as advertised, with the AMOLED displays consuming more power but remaining efficient.
- GPS Modes: The Instinct 3 Solar Edition offers unlimited power in GPS-only mode, outlasting the Fenix 8 in similar conditions.
- AMOLED vs. Solar: AMOLED models prioritize display quality, while solar models focus on efficiency and longevity.
- Real-World Use: The Fenix 8 balances features and battery life, whereas the Instinct 3 excels in endurance scenarios.
- Feature Trade-offs: The Fenix 8 includes advanced software features that may impact battery life, while the Instinct 3 focuses on core functionality and efficiency.
By understanding your needs and prioritizing the right features, you can select the model that best aligns with your lifestyle and activities.
Software and Features
Sport Profiles
Both the Garmin Instinct 3 and Fenix 8 offer an impressive array of sport profiles, making them versatile tools for athletes and adventurers alike. The vast majority of sport modes are identical across both models, with only a few exclusive to the Fenix 8.
Exclusive Fenix 8 Sport Profiles:
- Scuba Diving
- Free Diving
- Sailing
- Sailing Expedition
- Adventure Racing
- Ultra Running
- Mountaineering
- Jump Rope (curiously absent from the Instinct 3)
These differences primarily cater to niche sports or specialized use cases, such as underwater activities and high-altitude mountaineering. For most users, the sport profiles available on the Instinct 3 will cover nearly all common activities, from running and cycling to swimming and yoga.
Sensor Support
The sensor support story is similar. Both watches support a wide range of ANT+ and Bluetooth sensors, such as heart rate monitors, cycling power meters, and foot pods. However, the Fenix 8 adds compatibility with a few additional sensors, reinforcing its position as a more advanced device for serious athletes and adventurers.
Shared Features
A significant number of features are identical between the two watches, highlighting Garmin’s consistency in delivering core functionality across its lineup. Key shared features include:
- Activity and Sleep Tracking: Comprehensive metrics, including step counts, sleep stages, and recovery data.
- HRV Tracking: Heart Rate Variability data for stress monitoring and training readiness.
- Health and Fitness Metrics: VO2 max, training load, and advanced performance insights.
- Garmin Share: Wirelessly share files, such as course routes, between devices—even without cellular coverage.
- GPS Accuracy: Both devices feature industry-leading multi-band GPS and SatIQ technology for exceptional location tracking across various environments.
This parity ensures that users of both devices can rely on consistent health, fitness, and navigation performance.
Mapping and Navigation
One of the most notable software distinctions is mapping capability. The Fenix 8 includes comprehensive mapping features, such as:
- Offline contour maps
- Detailed trails, roads, and landmarks
- Turn-by-turn navigation
In contrast, the Instinct 3 relies on breadcrumb-style navigation without detailed maps. This limitation means users must follow a straight line to their destination, as the Instinct lacks offline routing and terrain visualization.
For users engaging in long hikes or complex routes, the mapping features of the Fenix 8 are invaluable.
ClimbPro and Advanced Metrics
The Fenix 8 also includes ClimbPro, a feature designed for mountain enthusiasts. ClimbPro automatically provides details about upcoming ascents, including distance, elevation gain, and gradient. This is particularly useful for long climbs, helping users pace themselves and understand how much effort remains.
The absence of ClimbPro on the Instinct 3 is a significant drawback for those who frequently venture into mountainous terrain.
Optical Heart Rate Sensor
The optical heart rate sensors differ between the two models:
- Fenix 8: Features the Gen 5 Optical Heart Rate Sensor, which includes ECG capabilities and improved accuracy, especially in challenging conditions like cold-weather runs and high-intensity workouts.
- Instinct 3: Equipped with the older Gen 4 Optical Heart Rate Sensor, which performs well in most scenarios but struggles under extreme conditions.
For users who demand the highest level of accuracy, the Fenix 8’s Gen 5 sensor is a significant upgrade.
Additional Software Differences
Several advanced features are exclusive to the Fenix 8, including:
- Endurance and Hill Scores: Metrics for long-distance and elevation-based performance.
- Cycling Ability and Stamina Features: Ideal for serious cyclists.
- Jet Lag Advisor: Guidance for mitigating jet lag during travel.
- Voice Features: Voice assistance, commands, and notes, along with the ability to make calls.
- Widgets: Includes countdowns, recovery, and stock tracking widgets, absent on the Instinct 3.
- Ski Maps and Round-Trip Routing: Enhanced features for winter sports and route planning.
Real-World Usage
For users who prioritize simplicity and long battery life, the Instinct 3 delivers a robust experience without unnecessary complications. Its features are more than adequate for everyday fitness tracking and outdoor adventures.
However, the Fenix 8 stands out for advanced users, offering a more comprehensive suite of tools and software tailored to endurance athletes, explorers, and tech enthusiasts.
Final Verdict
Garmin Fenix 8
- Best For: Advanced users, outdoor enthusiasts, and athletes seeking premium features, detailed mapping, and high-end hardware.
- Strengths: Touchscreen, premium materials, advanced health metrics, and extensive software features.
- Drawbacks: High price point and slightly heavier design.
Garmin Instinct 3
- Best For: Casual users, budget-conscious buyers, and those prioritizing battery life and rugged durability.
- Strengths: Affordable, lightweight, and exceptional battery performance in solar models.
- Drawbacks: Lacks advanced mapping, touchscreen, and premium materials.
Ultimately, the choice between the Garmin Instinct 3 and the Garmin Fenix 8 depends on your specific needs and budget. If you’re an avid adventurer who values detailed maps, advanced metrics, and high-end materials, the Fenix 8 is worth the investment. However, if you’re looking for a reliable, rugged watch with excellent battery life at a lower cost, the Instinct 3 is a perfect choice.
The Instinct 3 offers a robust set of features that cater to outdoor enthusiasts and fitness-focused individuals who don’t require the advanced capabilities of the Fenix 8. Its durability, exceptional battery life, and reliable core functionality make it a practical and cost-effective option for most users. Ultimately, both watches excel in their own right, so your decision should align with your specific priorities and how you plan to use the device.